Example: AB12 CDE
4.9 on Trustpilot Premium dataData from Experian
Full report £11.99 · No subscription · See what’s included
Car Buyer Advice

Used Car MOT History Explained: How Our Vehicle Score Works

CarCheckUp Editorial Team · Updated 9 min read
Used Car MOT History Explained: How Our Vehicle Score Works

Every free car check on CarCheckUp now opens with a vehicle score from 0 to 100. It sums up what a used car's MOT history, mileage readings and DVLA status say about it, and, in a full report, its finance, write-off and stolen records too. This guide explains how to read those records yourself and exactly how the score is worked out, point by point.

The short answer: what the vehicle score is

The score starts at 100 and is built the way a vehicle inspector would weigh a car. It separates three kinds of sign:

  • History records, such as outstanding finance, an insurance write-off, a stolen marker or a mileage reading lower than an earlier one. These are the real risks, so they cost the most and also set a ceiling on the score.
  • The car's state now: a failed latest MOT, a dangerous defect or no valid MOT. These are things you would have to fix first.
  • Normal wear: age, mileage, advisories, past MOT fails and similar signs. Every used car has some, so they are judged against the car's age and together can cost no more than 25 points.

That means a well-kept used car with a clean history scores Excellent, a car showing the wear you'd expect for its age scores Good, and a car with a serious record can't score well however tidy its MOTs look. The result falls into one of five bands:

ScoreBandWhat it suggests
85 to 100ExcellentA clean history and a well-kept car for its age
70 to 84GoodA clean history with wear or something to ask about: high mileage, several advisories, a gap without an MOT
55 to 69FairA record to deal with before buying, such as outstanding finance or a Category N or S write-off
40 to 54PoorClear warning signs, such as a mileage reading lower than an earlier one
0 to 39Very poorSerious records, such as a stolen marker or a Category A or B write-off

Under the score the report lists every point lost and what counts in the car's favour, so you can see why it scored what it did.

Reading the MOT history: what matters most

The MOT history is the best free record of how a car has been looked after. Across the 492,751 vehicles checked on CarCheckUp, 77% of MOT tests were passed and the average test recorded 1.5 advisories. When you look at a car's own history, focus on these:

  • The latest test. A recent fail, or a dangerous defect, is the clearest sign of work still to be done. A pass with no advisories is the best result there is.
  • Advisories on the latest test. Advisories are defects that are not yet a failure: tyres close to the limit, worn brake pads, light corrosion. A long list means a bill is coming. In our data the most common advisory areas are tyres, brakes, suspension and corrosion.
  • Repeated fails. One fail years ago means little. Several fails in the last two years suggest a car that keeps needing work.
  • Corrosion. Corrosion on brake pipes, subframes or sills can be expensive, and it gets worse with time.
  • Outstanding recalls. A safety recall the manufacturer is still waiting to fix.

You can see a car's full MOT history, every test with its advisories and failures, in our free MOT history check.

Mileage: the reading that should only go up

Every MOT records the odometer reading, so a car's mileage history should only ever rise. 5.7% of the vehicles we checked have a reading lower than an earlier one. That can be a typing error or a replaced instrument cluster, but it can also be a clocked car, so it is the biggest deduction in the free check score and holds the score at 45 or below until the seller can explain it. Our free mileage check compares every reading.

Mileage is judged two ways. The total matters because expensive parts such as the clutch, suspension and cambelt come due as miles build up: over 100,000, 150,000 and 200,000 miles each cost a little more. How hard the car was used matters too: the typical car in our data covers about 7,500 miles a year (vans more, so we allow 12,000 for them), and a car covering one and a half times that loses a further 2 points. Mileage can cost at most 7 points, because age is counted separately. A gap of more than two years between readings is also worth asking about.

Age, tax and MOT status

Age lowers the score only a little, as wear: 2 points over 10 years, 4 over 15 and 5 over 20. The MOT history shows how well the car has aged, which matters more than the date on the log book. A long gap between MOT tests is different: if a car went more than 15 months without one, it was off the road or driven without an MOT, so it is flagged separately for you to ask about. The DVLA status matters for a different reason: a car with no valid MOT can't legally be driven on the road (except to a booked MOT), and a car that is untaxed or declared off the road (SORN) needs sorting before you can drive it away. The free check also shows the car's tax date, an estimate of its road tax and whether it is likely to meet the London ULEZ standard.

What the full report adds, and why it weighs most

A free check can't show the records that cost buyers the most money. These come from Experian and the Police National Computer and are only in the full report. Across 4,403 full reports run on CarCheckUp:

  • 16.7% had outstanding finance. If a car still belongs to a lender, it can be taken back. See our finance check.
  • 13.4% had an insurance write-off record. A Category S or N car can be repaired and sold, but the record lowers its value. See our write-off check.
  • 34.1% had a number plate change. Usually a private plate, but it can separate a car from its history.
  • Stolen markers are rare, 17 of the 4,403 reports, but buying a stolen car can leave you with neither the car nor your money. See our stolen car check.

Because these records matter most, they carry the heaviest deductions in the full report score and set a ceiling on it: a car with outstanding finance can't score above 60, whatever its MOTs say. The free check's score leaves them out and says so: a car with a clean MOT history can still have finance owing or a write-off on record.

The formula: every point, in full

These are the deductions from 100. The score can't go below 0, and a history record also sets the highest score the car can have.

History records and the car's state now

SignPointsHighest possible score
A mileage reading lower than an earlier one−2545
The latest MOT was a fail−10
A dangerous defect at the latest MOT−10
No valid MOT−8
More than 15 months between two MOT tests (the MOT ran out)−5
An outstanding manufacturer recall−3
Recorded as stolen (full report)−6010
Insurance write-off: Category A or B / C / S or D / N (full report)−60 / −35 / −30 / −2020 / 45 / 55 / 65
Recorded as scrapped (full report)−4030
Outstanding finance (full report)−3060
On the high risk register (full report)−2065
A Vehicle Identity Check (VIC) on record (full report)−5
Exported or marked for export (full report)−5

Normal wear: at most 25 points in total

SignPoints
More advisories at the latest MOT than normal for its age (2, plus 1 for every 4 years)−2 for each extra, up to −8
Other failed MOTs in the last 2 years (each)−3, up to −6
MOT pass rate (3 or more tests): 60 to 74% / under 60%−3 / −5
Corrosion noted at one of the last two MOTs−3
Mileage over 100,000 / 150,000 / 200,000−3 / −5 / −7
Heavy use: over 1.5 times the normal miles a year (8,000 for a car, 12,000 for a van)−2 (mileage at most −7 in all)
A gap of over 2 years between mileage readings−2
Age: over 10 / 15 / 20 years−2 / −4 / −5
Untaxed or SORN−2
Signs of taxi or private hire use (full report)−5
Previous keepers: 4 to 6 / 7 or more (full report)−1 / −3
Colour changed / imported (full report)−2

What counts in a car's favour, such as a clean latest MOT, no fails in two years, mileage that is normal for its age or a single previous keeper, is listed in the report too, so you can see both sides.

What the score can't tell you

The score reads records, not the car in front of you. It can't see how the car drives, whether the service history is genuine or what has been fixed since the last MOT. Use it to decide which cars are worth a closer look and which questions to ask, then inspect the car, take it for a test drive and check the V5C log book matches. Our guide to questions to ask when buying a used car helps with that part.

Frequently asked questions

Is the vehicle score free?

Yes. Every free car check shows a score from the MOT history, mileage and DVLA status. The full report's score also counts finance, write-off, stolen and keeper records.

Why did a car with a clean MOT score lower in the full report?

Because the full report found a record the free check can't see, such as outstanding finance or a write-off. Those carry the heaviest deductions and cap the score.

Why doesn't an older car with a few advisories score badly?

Because some wear is normal for a used car. Advisories and mileage are compared with what is typical for the car's age, and all wear signs together can cost at most 25 points. The score is meant to flag real risks, not to mark every used car down.

Does a high score mean the car is safe to buy?

No score can promise that. A high score means its records show no warning signs; you should still inspect the car and check its paperwork.

Where do the figures come from?

MOT and mileage data come from the DVSA, vehicle details and tax status from the DVLA, and the full report's records from Experian and the Police National Computer. The percentages in this guide come from our UK Used Car Risk Report.

Check a car now: enter its registration for a free car check with its vehicle score, or see a sample full report to see everything the full check includes.

Was this guide helpful?

Follow new guides by RSS

Looking at a Used Car Right Now?

Don't risk thousands on a vehicle with outstanding finance or past write-off damage. Run an instant check with official DVLA & Experian data.

Check Any UK Reg Plate Now